Cat Deeley’s Look
Kate: Yaaaaaaaaaas THIS is my favorite version of Cat Deeley hair.
Erica: Yes. Yes. Yes. Well, this is probably my second favorite. I like it when there are just those big loose curls at the bottom a scooch better. But God she is so pretty. I want to brush it.
Kate: And only someone a bazillion feet tall, like her, with teeny-tiny skinny arms, also like her, could pull off that dress. Love it love it love it.
Erica: I think she looks great in that dress. That dress is not my particular thing, but it is a perfect example of the thing it is.
Group Routine – All: Hip-hop, choreo by Luther Brown
“Ya Ya” by Jonte
Kate: Why was no one nearly as sharp as they needed to be, all-stars included?
Erica: Here’s what I was thinking during this routine: Okay, so it’s African jazz? But what’s the difference between African jazz and jazz, other than outfits? Well, this is sharper and harder than most jazz. More like hip-hop. Is African jazz just hip-hop with different outfits? And then it was hip-hop after all. In African jazz outfits. But it’s still not clear to me what distinguishes African jazz from other dance forms.
Kate: I did not like the outfits, or the routine, at all.
Logan & Allison: Jive, choreo by Emma Slater & Sasha Farber
“5 Months, 2 weeks, 2 days” by Louis Prima
Kate: I do not feel that his feet were as good in this, and your feet HAVE to be good in a jive. That’s the whole point!
Erica: Oh, I enjoyed this quite a bit. There was still a lot of contemporary in him, but I thought he did very well. Maybe it’s just that I love a jive.
Kate: Ugh but I LOVE when Mary Murphy gets all technical in her critiques, reminds me that she actually knows what she’s talking about as opposed to *SOME* other judges.
Erica: I know; I kind of want Mary Murphy to give us a little class some time. Like, get some of the ballroom all-stars on stage and be like, “Look, this is what the feet are supposed to do during a samba/waltz/foxtrot, this is what the arms are supposed to do,” etc.
Kate: “Wow…You guys, like…really DANCED, you know? Heehee!” *eye roll*
Erica: Vanessa Hudgens is so terrible. You know, I was going to show Zoe High School Musical now that she’s the right age for it but I think I won’t. (She also hates Vanessa Hudgens, so that’s fine.) Why couldn’t they have Christina Applegate?
Kate: She was fine in that movie and Zoe would like it, she is just not fine as a So You Think You Can Dance judge. I think something *happened* with Christina Applegate and Fox.
Kione & Marko: Hip-hop, choreo by David Scott
“You Don’t Own Me” by Grace feat. G-Eazy
Kate: Trying not to focus on the fact that one of my favorite songs by one of my all-time favorite singers has been turned into a hip-hop remix, I looooovvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvved this routine.
Erica: They didn’t even remix it that well. It was just kind of that song, with some hip-hop bits in between. But yes, this routine was brilliant and she was brilliant in it. Like, seriously, seriously brilliant.
Kate: Kione is so so good. She is great at hip-hop, she is great with Marko, she’s even starting to outshine him a little.
Erica: Yeah. Yeah, she is.
Dassy & Fik-Shun: Jazz, choreo by Ray Leeper
“Bring the Funk Back” by Big Gigantic
Kate: This was fun, and again the contestant was outshining the all-star, a bit. I think this style suited her well.
Erica: I am more and more impressed by Dassy. I actually thought she was better than him in this. Or at least more comfortable being sexy. Funk is clearly a good style for him, but she was great.
Mark & Comfort: Contemporary, choreo by Talia Favia
“Ending” by Isaiah Danielson
Kate: She is such a beautiful dancer. I am unimpressed by him overall.
Erica: So I agree that she is more or less carrying him, but this one hit me in all the feels. This was another unhealthy romance piece, with more violence and more despair, and I really felt it. It hit me.
Kate: No pun intended?
Group Routine – All Stars: Contemporary, choreo by Travis Wall
“Strange Fruit” Nina Simone
Kate: Well this was a bit jarring.
Erica: I hate “issues” pieces. I hate pieces that rely on you watching on TV rather than being in the live audience. And yet. I thought this was magnificent. Beautiful choreography. Astounding performances. Just a beautiful piece of art. In my opinion.
Kate: I’m surprised this was a Travis Wall routine, but I won’t say anything else for fear of being misinterpreted.
Erica: It’s okay, Kate. You can dislike this piece and also still hate racism. I must confess, I was completely confused about how they got out of their first outfits. I had to rewind and watch again and I’m still a bit confused.
Kate: Oh, yes, the outfits confused me. It was beautifully danced.
Lex & Gaby: Broadway, choreo by Warren Carlyle
“Miss Otis Regrets” by Bette Midler
Kate: I WANT her dress, except I’d wear it as a tank top.
Erica: She looked incredible. I love this song and she was so good. He was…There? I’m not really sure about that; most of the dance didn’t seem to want me to notice him.
Kate: I am as unimpressed with Lex as I am with Mark, I think.
Sydney & Paul: Hip-hop, choreo by Luther Brown
“Really? Yeah!” by Kyle
Kate: Ah, these two can’t really do hip-hop, can they?
Erica: No. Sydney was doing the same shoulders-hunched-equals-swag thing that fellow ballroom-er Kiki was doing last week.
Kate: For once I agreed with the judges, she was too cutesy/smiley in this. I continue to dislike the odd things she does with her mouth.
Erica: She was just sort of smirking the whole time. I think she thought that was swag as well.
Kate: None of what she does, ever, is “swag”.
Group Routine – Top 9: Broadway, choreo by Chris Baldock
“Hey Pachuco!” by Royal Crown Revue
Kate: At first I thought this was just the guys — contestants and all-stars — and then I was like, ‘Wait, why are there so many guys?’ and then I realized the girls were in it too. The suits and hairstyles threw me off.
Erica: You are so funny. I must say, I hated the suits.
Kate: Me too. Didn’t love any of the group routines tonight, really.
Erica: This routine should have done it for me and it did not. But maybe I was distracted by the weird-a$s suits.
Kaylee & Cyrus: Jazz, choreo by Spencer Liff
“Less Talk, More Art” by Vito Fun & Koil
Kate: I really thought I did not like her at first, but last week and this week she has really grown on me. Maybe Cyrus brings it out in her.
Erica: They were very good. She was very good. But more than that, this routine was very, very good. It was fun and cute and sharp and difficult enough to show off their skills while still being a coherent piece. And I liked the hats. Good job, Spencer Liff.
Taylor & Robert: Samba, choreo by Jean-Marc Genereux
“Bun Up the Dance” by Dillon Francis & Skrillex
Kate: Dammit. I loved these 2, but they didn’t live up to weeks 1 and 2 with this routine. She was WAY too stiff and rigid in her back for this particular ballroom style, it just wasn’t as fluid as it was supposed to be.
Erica: See, I didn’t think she was nearly as bad as they were saying! Yes, a little rigid in the back, but, you know, they slobbered all over Lex and Logan and were very forgiving of their minor missteps, and much harder on Taylor for, I think, similar flaws.
Kate: Yes, because she was SO GOOD the last 2 weeks. Robert looked like he wanted to KILL someone when the judges were giving them criticism. You were obviously great, Robert, it’s Taylor that stunk up the place! We still love YOU!
Kiki & Jenna: Contemporary, choreo by Mandy Moore
“The First Time Ever I Saw Your Face” by George Michael
Kate: This song makes me sad because I think it’s the song Mom and Dad heard on their first date and he thought she didn’t know anything about music and asked her who sang it (the original, not George Michael) and she did know.
Erica: Really? That’s a good story. I like it.
Kate: Everyone was all hyped up about their chemistry in this, and I didn’t really see it, but I did like him more than I have before in this routine. He can stay.
Erica: I mean, he was fine and the piece was nice, but she’s become one of those people where, she could be saving puppies and curing cancer on stage and I’d still be having this overwhelming “Ugh” reaction so I don’t know if I can be objective about them.
Kate: Good, Sydney in the bottom 3 again. Oh good, Sydney going home. Bye, weird mouth!
Erica: I can’t believe Dassy was on the bottom. Right now, she, Kione, and Taylor (yes, still) are my favorites. I am ready to say goodbye to Kiki and Lex. And if I could lose Mark without losing Comfort, I would. I’m fine with the Sydney decision. Bottom 3 twice in a row? Sure, time to go.
Kate: I also do not like that Dassy was in the bottom. Get it together, America (in many ways).